Girl Guide:
A Woman’s Experience in Outdoor Guiding
“Cheers to no panty-hose!” Amy raised her trekking poles to cheers with the group as we reached the summit of Hawksbill Mountain in Shenandoah National Park. We had hiked over 2,000 feet of elevation from the bottom of a canyon to the highest peak in the park on one of the hottest days of the summer — no easy feat. I was guiding a group of 7 women ranging in ages from mid-50s to mid-70s on a women’s trip, one specifically designed to bring women together to make friends and share their love of the outdoors together.
So far, the day had been filled with connection and challenge, with emotions rising and falling like the elevation on the Appalachian Trail. Already, the women had bonded over lost family members, body image struggles, life-changing trips, and childhood memories. The guests educated me on the old days of etiquette school and rules by Emily Post. They recited a chapter about attending a date with a man, where women were instructed not to speak to the waiter unless invited by a man. They reminisced about wearing panty-hose and shared their deep relief that they could now wear wool socks and pants on this hike. They had decided that by now their panty hose would be covered in runs, and their hiking boots would have simply slipped right off their feet.
I had been guiding with various companies for five years at this point, but this was my first all-women’s trip. I wasn’t expecting the kind of comfort that I myself felt in the group. Maybe it was the perfect combination of personalities, but there was something about being able to freely discuss the function of a SheWee without embarrassment that was completely freeing. It was a new type of freedom that I hadn’t experienced with a group before.
Since I was young, I’ve always felt like I’ve had to “prove myself” athletically. In gym class, others would be surprised by my participation, and in classrooms teachers would breeze by me when they needed help from a “strong boy”. I sat back and watched, feeling unseen and “less than” the others. Now, as an adult in the outdoor industry, these moments don’t affect me as much emotionally, although they definitely still affect me. Being in such a physical job, people see my small physique and question my abilities. They ask me if I am an “assistant guide” at first glance rather than believe a small girl could be their lead.
I have worked with so many amazing co-guides who were not women — most of them extremely self-aware and inclusive. I have learned so much from their guidance and experience, and I am endlessly grateful for their advice. I would not be the guide that I am today without them. However, even without mal-intent, there is still bias. While my coworkers of all genders know that I am a capable person, there is always a slight underlying assumption that my strength and technical experience is less than others around me. It is frustrating to be the last in line, to be assumed weak, scared, unknowing or inexperienced. While I am used to this by now and have definitely learned how to deal with it, I have found that working in an environment without this type of interaction is entirely game-changing. The ease that I feel when I’m surrounded by others who can fully respect and appreciate my experience is profound. The little voice in the back of my head that nags at me to “prove myself” completely disappears and gives me so much more space to fully focus. I feel like a better person, leader, and guide.
Guiding with my co-guide on this trip, Hannah, felt seamless, with no accidental power dynamics, over-explaining, or tip-toeing. The guests trusted me for safety and guidance. I felt empowered and strong. It was crucial for me to have the experience of feeling fully confident in this group. I felt like I was at my peak guide state — fully aware, present, and confident. Now, as I guide in every type of group with all types of people, I channel this version of myself, because I know that she’s in there. As a young girl, I never honestly envisioned that I could do this kind of work. It was a pipe dream, a dream for someone else to fulfill. I’ve worked hard to be where I am. I am proud to be a guide, and I want to continue making younger me proud by pushing myself to keep learning and growing every day. I want to make it easier for future women to step into guide roles, and I want to show all women that they belong outdoors. I am grateful for this challenge and this community, but I am most grateful that I don’t have to wear panty-hose.
Brain Freeze:
Returning to the Wall After a Traumatic Brain Injury
My legs shook like Elvis as I looked down to my most recent clip, about two feet below my feet. I glanced down at Fran who was patiently belaying me and sending encouraging words my way. I tried to swallow my embarrassment at being frozen on a climb that I had done many times before. There were tons of climbers at Birdsboro that Saturday, some of them already waiting for me to finish my climb.
It had been just over a year since I was T-boned by a driver running a red light, sustained a serious concussion and was out of work as a guide for eight months straight. For over a year, I couldn’t even think about climbing. After all that time, tons of physical therapy, and lots of sitting in a dark room, I was finally cleared by my neurologist to get back on the wall. I did a slow-burn reintroduction back into climbing, starting with small walls in the gym and staying on top rope. But now, it was time to try leading again. I had been preparing to take my Single-Pitch Instructor course in a few months, so I had to make sure I was ready. Physically, I was. What I wasn’t prepared for was the emotional change that had happened to me in the past year since I had climbed last.
Now, something was stopping me from climbing. There was a huge mental block. A crushing, unmanageable fear, one that was completely new to me. I went from being stoked to take leaps and go for big reaches to suddenly being paralyzed on the wall.
Although I hadn’t gotten my concussion while climbing, the risk of injury while up on the wall was omnipresent. The possibility of landing back in my bedroom, alone, in the dark, was getting me stuck. It is true that climbing is much safer than it looks when you have the proper training, safety practices, and equipment. However — all the safety practices in the world can’t erase the fact that you are literally dangling from a wall. The risk is there. And I knew that too well.
While I stood frozen on the wall, my mind went in 100 different directions. I wondered if I would be restricted to top-roping forever, never to lead or trad climb again. I wondered what decision-making process even got me into climbing. I questioned my career path and my sanity. I gripped the wall for dear life, like I had never climbed before.
“You got this O’Hara. Take your time.” Fran broke me out of my trance. He knew why I was stuck.
I turned around to look at the view from the wall. I tried to remember why I was up there. Yes, climbing and instructing is my job. But it’s much more than that — the reason I climb is for myself, to push myself, and to grow. Ultimately, I don’t climb to make big gains, look cool, or send the highest grade. I’m up here for myself, to show myself what I can do. Sometimes, obstacles get in the way, but that doesn’t mean that I’m not learning and growing up here on the wall.
In the end, I took the fall. I didn’t finish the climb, even though I knew that I physically could. It felt like a failure in the moment, but it was what I needed. I know that it was actually the harder thing to do. Even after all that physical therapy, I still had some rehab to do. I still had to work to get back to where I was mentally. But I would do it. I uncovered a new barricade in front of the finish line that I hadn’t seen before. So, I made an action plan: I would lead climb in the gym three to four times a week, I would go to Birdsboro every Sunday. I would practice falling to get used to it — and not push myself or bully myself when I was simply too scared.
Climbing will never be a low-risk sport. That is why I practice, take courses, read books and keep learning: to make the risk as low as possible. Because the challenge is what keeps me coming back. It’s not just a physical challenge like lifting weights. It’s a mental exercise as well. To me, nothing feels better than summiting a climb knowing that it took not only strength but courage, perseverance, and mental fortitude. While I am not grateful that I was in a bad car accident, I’m grateful for the new perspective it gave me on my climbing practice. I don’t take it for granted: every climb is a marathon and every summit is an accumulation of my physical efforts, mental work and emotional tenacity.
Hashtags vs. Shopping Bags:
REI’s #OptOutside Campaign as an Environmental Actor Against Consumerism
For years, Black Friday has been a holiday almost more momentous than Thanksgiving itself for thrifty shoppers and bargain finders. Americans knock down doors and cause stampedes at Best Buys (literally) to get their hands on holiday deals. The self-proclaimed “holiday” not only promotes somewhat un-extraordinary sales, but it creates a convention of consumerism that the country has fallen prey to. Many stores have even started opening on Thanksgiving Day to draw in more shoppers, in turn pulling people away from quality family time.
While many stores bask in the glory of Black Friday, Recreational Equipment Inc. (REI) has turned its back on the holiday. To combat this era of consumerism, the corporation has created the #OptOutside campaign, closing its doors on Black Friday and urging shoppers to go outside instead. The campaign asks people to share their outside activities on social media platforms with their hashtag to show others how they are spending their Black Fridays. By using social media to construct an appealing image of the environment, REI’s campaign has become not only an incredibly effective marketing strategy for their own products, but also an uplifting advocate for environmental awareness and engagement.
CAMPAIGN SUMMARY: Stepping Away from the Black Friday “Norm”
The #OptOutside campaign ranges across many media platforms, pressuring REI’s audiences not to give into consumerism, and instead to spend time outside. Through videos, Instagram, blog posts, and more, REI members and followers are exposed to expansive landscape shots emblazoned with the hashtag, reminding them of the benefits of spending time outdoors this Black Friday. REI President and CEO Jerry Stritzke explains how, as a co-op, REI does not just define success as how much they sell, but more as “how effectively do [they] get people outside?” (Malcolm, 2015).
The store is taking even further steps to promote “going out with them”; not only are all 143 store locations’ doors closed, but their 12,000 employees are still paid (“Will you go out with us?”, 2016; Chokshi, 2015). The extra pay is meant to give employees even more incentive to spend the day exploring nature. Staff members are thankful for this opportunity: employee Jessie Dickerson praises REI for “the chance to go out and explore what nature has to offer with [their] loved ones during the holidays” (Niggemeyer, Kennett, Carpenter, & Tolentino, 2015). CEO Stritzke explains, “We really want this to be a day when people are outdoors” (Bhattarai, 2017). While he at first was nervous to start the campaign because he was worried about the public’s reactions, Stritzke soon realized that “it doesn’t matter what the public thinks”, and that it is more important that REI upholds what it stands for, giving families time outside (Niggemeyer, Kennett, Carpenter, & Tolentino, 2015). REI’s separation from societal pressures to give in to consumerism puts them a step ahead of other organizations, who have not yet moved away from the norm.
The campaign, which started in 2015, has started to pick up speed and spread to other organizations and areas, showing its overall influence. Over 700 organizations followed REI in closing their doors on Black Friday (REI - #OptOutside Case Study, 2016). Many government agencies not only became a part of the social media campaign, but also decided to open their parks up for free (Chokshi, 2015). Both Tennessee and Arizona paired with REI, with store locations handing out free day-passes for state parks (Chokshi, 2015). Delaware and Oregon both waived park fees for Black Friday, and Kansas even named REI in announcing a contest for a free overnight stay in a state park cabin, encouraging people to “take a break, get out, and enjoy some fresh air” (Chokshi, 2015). Washington, Minnesota, Colorado, and Missouri have all opened up a number of their parks for free as well (Chokshi, 2015). All of these actions are promoting REI’s attempt to take what USA Today reports as a “direct aim at the frenzied consumerism that dominates the holidays with a message to do the exact opposite of what Black Friday demands” (Malcolm, 2015). The spreading of this incentive shows the success that the campaign has had in gaining traction and support.
CONSTRUCTION: The Environment as a Haven for Community
The multitude of platforms that this campaign appears upon allows REI to create a vision of the environment that is engaging and attractive to viewers. It is clear that the strategy has been effective just from the numbers: the campaign started trending quickly after it was released, and had 2.7 million PR impressions within 24 hours (REI - #OptOutside Case Study, 2016). REI’s social media mentions rose by an incredible 7,000% (REI - #OptOutside Case Study, 2016). Altogether, the hashtag earned over 6.7 billion media impressions and inspired 7 million people to opt outside (REI - #OptOutside Case Study, 2016).
Along with the popularity, the campaign represents the environment in a way that audiences connect with. In a series of promotional YouTube videos, REI contrasts consumerism and environmentalism by showing the stark visual and audio contrasts of nature and cities. The video #OptOutside: Camping Out Again is a 30-second ad that depicts various people in tents, camping in a serene environment, opposing the audio of a busy and chaotic newscast about the madness of Black Friday (#OptOutside: Camping Out Again, 2016). At the end of the clip, the radio audio cuts out, leaving only nature sounds with a beautiful wide landscape shot. This abrupt transition highlights the polarity between busy, consumerist Black Friday lives and #OptOutside lives, and makes viewers desire the calm of nature. Another video, #OptOutside: Will You Go Out With Me?, shows a montage of young, happy people packing a backpack, leaving their homes in the city, and driving to the coast or to a forest to hike, kayak, bike, or swim (#OptOutside: Will You Go Out With Me?, 2016). The video pushes people to separate themselves from a busy, bustling city life and treat themselves to time in the relaxing natural environment. Both of these videos construct the environment as a haven that people who are not participating in #OptOutside are missing out on.
Along with videos and ads, REI created a blog that allows audiences to gain a more personal, yet still informative, experience with the campaign. The Opt Outside website has options allowing visitors to plan a trip, take a class with the REI Outdoor School, or learn from outdoor expert advice. REI also created a search engine for outdoor activities, where people can search for nearby opportunities such as hiking, rowing, and rock climbing (Bhattarai, 2017). Finally, there is an Opt Outside blog, including stories ranging from the history of Opt Outside to tips for having a successful first hike. The blog adds an even more community-driven feel to the campaign, giving people the opportunity to find their own material to engage with and apply knowledge to their own experiences. This sense of community shapes the environment as a group experience, in which people will gain personal and social fulfillment.
Furthermore, and possibly the most influential, the Opt Outside hashtag allows viewers to collect all posts from other REI members and campaign participants on every form of social media. This puts all of the community’s photos, videos, and experiences in one condensed spot with easy access. With a simple swipe, people are opened up to inspiration from people all over the world, encouraging them to get outside. This creates a feeling of collective and oneness with a group, even though they may not know the people whose photos they are viewing. Even further, it adds a participation aspect, allowing people to feel as though they contributed to the cause. This is a huge driver for people to participate, allowing them to gain their own personal publicity and approval. It also allows REI to display a much larger array of environmental photos and opportunities by giving anyone the ability to contribute. This gives viewers a much better chance of consuming material that they feel personally connected to, whether it be an uncommon outdoor activity that they enjoy or a small park near their home that they are familiar with.
AGENCY: The Voice of the Audience
The entire #OptOutside campaign leaves the door open for the audience to have the agency. The term “opt” literally leaves the decision up to the consumer: they can opt to shop on Black Friday, or make the noble choice and opt outside. Once they opt outside, it is then also their decision to share their experience. When they do this, they become the voice of the campaign, adding to the media collective of experiences that other consumers will use to view the campaign. So, in turn, the audience becomes the voice of the environment. In this case, the environment is the enemy of consumerism, a theme that is generally connected to “evil” themes, such as waste, greed, and disconnection. When people choose to reject consumerism, they feel as though they are doing the “right” thing.
This campaign specifically targets young people and users of social media. This particular age group is drawn to community-based interactions, and is often targeted by marketers with images of young groups of people having experiences together, which is the basis of the Opt Outside campaign. One branch of the campaign is entirely dedicated to this, as it asks people, “Will you go out with us?” (“Will you go out with us?”, 2016). The #OptOutside: Will You Go Out With Me? video is posted with the caption: “Outdoors will be closed on [Black Friday], but we won’t be alone. Ask your favorite people to #OptOutside with you on Black Friday and we can all go out with each other” (#OptOutside: Will you go out with me?, 2016). This caption creates a feeling of “us” and community between REI and its members. The caption ensuring people that “we won’t be alone” because we will be going out “with each other” makes young viewers excited for the experience of going outside with their friends. This even further promotes active involvement in the campaign, as they as are encouraged to ask their friends to participate with them as well.
FINAL THOUGHTS: Media Campaigns as a Growing Medium for Change
With REI’s new campaign addressing young media consumers, the span of its videos, photos, and hashtags has reached greater lengths and painted an incredibly positive picture of environmentalism. This picture leaves people wishing to get involved, and therefore drives them to get outside instead of shopping on Black Friday. It makes the audience themselves the environmental actors, and therefore makes an even wider campaign than otherwise possible with just corporation resources. It has been tackling the issue of consumerism on Black Friday, but its impact spans much further than that, addressing environmental activism at the same time. Not only does this campaign effectively combat consumerism, but its use of the environment as an anti-consumerist agent also promotes environmental action and participation. This use of an attractive and easily accessible campaign with simple, yet gripping, visuals on effective mediums opens up environmentalism to an entirely new field of activism. Media campaigns promote participation of the audience, and therefore makes consumers feel involved and relevant. This type of campaign has a promising future in accelerating people’s relationships with nature. If other environmental organizations continue to use this new form of media to create active campaigns, the possibility for environmental involvement is promising. Not only can it tackle the issue of consumerism and Black Friday, but a huge array of relevant environmental issues that can make incredible change in the environmental community.
Works Cited
Bhattarai, A. (2017). REI thinks you have better things to do than shop on black Friday. (recreational equipment, inc.). The Washington Post doi:GALE|A512120285 Retrieved from http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A512120285/AONE?u=temple_main&sid=AONE&xid =8b1f8a05
Chokshi, N. (2015). These states are making it easy to take up REI on its black Friday #OptOutside campaign.(recreational equipment inc.). The Washington Post Retrieved from http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A435740844/AONE?u=temple_main&sid=AONE&xid =af38edf1
Malcolm, H. (2015). REI wants you to #OptOutside on black Friday.(MONEY)(recreational equipment inc.). USA Today Retrieved from http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A432951135/AONE?u=temple_main&sid=AONE&xid =649b1d90
Niggemeyer, N., Kennett, R., Carpenter, Z., & Tolentino, J. (2015). Many say 'no' to black Friday bargains. USA Today Retrieved from http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A434983152/AONE?u=temple_main&sid=AONE&x id=e2d92c78
#OptOutside: Camping Out Again. Recreational Equipment Inc. (Director). (2016).[Video/DVD] YouTube: Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LGAlIvE8fQQ
#OptOutside: Will you go out with me?. Recreational Equipment Inc. (Director). (2016). [Video/DVD] YouTube: Retrieved
from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MEVXU4RDUoI
REI - #OptOutside Case Study. McGinness, W. and Einhorn, L. (Directors). (2016).[Video/DVD] YouTube: Venables Bell & Partners. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lMsxrJeJ8lU
Will you go out with us? (2016). Parks & Recreation; Arlington, 51(11), 56. Retrieved from https://search-proquest-com.libproxy.temple.edu/docview/1844316008?accountid=14270